We’ve never had a problem with skin irritation, but Robbie HATES scented soaps. I mean he hates them with a passion, so we’ve had to hunt long and hard for soaps that don’t irritate his sensitive nose. Have you ever tried castille soap? Dr Bronner’s has a pure castille soap that we’ve used on an off again over the years (including our only soap for everything… dishes, bodies, laundry… when we lived in the Alaska woods for a summer). I wonder if that would work for your skin? Here’s a link to their website if you’re interested in exploring it further. https://www.drbronner.com/